The recruitment
If a Mafia member is voted out, the Godfather recruits a new member that night. The recruit wakes with the Mafia and still wakes with their original team. A double life begins.
The crooked cop
If a Detective is recruited, they become a Crooked Cop β still waking beside their partner, steering every investigation off course. Their partner suspects nothing.
π§ͺ The Quack
If a Doctor is recruited, they keep waking with the Doctors β quietly steering saves away from the truth. The moment they become the last Doctor standing (instantly, in a one-Doctor town), the Quack awakens. They still rise to the same "Doctors, wake up" call as always β but now their medicine is poison. The town's guardian angel may be its executioner.
π‘ The Godfather's choice
Once the Quack is active, the Mafia still claims one victim per night β but the Godfather chooses the weapon.
The Blade: instant. Certain. Revealed at dawn. But the Bodyguard can catch it.
The Poison: the Mafia stays home; the Quack administers the dose during the Doctor call. It bypasses the Bodyguard β you can't take a bullet that was never fired. But the poison is slowβ¦
βοΈ Justice is the antidote
When poison is used, the victim is tapped in secret, during the night β no one sees the Narrator's hand. At dawn there is no body β only the words: "Someone in this room is dying." Only the victim knows it's them. They have one day. They die at the next dawn β unless the Quack dies first. Find the poisoner, and the poison never completes.
Claim it aloud, or work in silence? Choose carefully β and remember: anyone can claim to be dying. Only the dawn tells the truth.
π¦Ί The Vest
The first time the Bodyguard intercepts a kill, he does not die. The Narrator taps him in secret, during the night. The dawn brings the words: "The Mafia struck last nightβ¦ and steel met steel. No one died." He now secretly holds the most valuable intel in the town β he alone knows who the Mafia tried to kill. But the Vest is spent. The second blade he catches goes through.
π
The hero's dawn
When the Bodyguard dies taking a blade for his ward, it is no ordinary death. The Narrator declares that a hero fell β and the Bodyguard earns the one exception to the law of the Graveyard: dying words. One sentence. Strictly one. Name your ward, point a finger, or go out with poetry β then the Undertaker takes you. Dead men tell no tales β but heroes get one sentence.
π‘ The turncoat
If the Bodyguard is recruited, he becomes the Turncoat. He still wakes, still points, still performs the hero β but when the blade falls on his ward, he simply steps aside. The town can never again trust that someone will die in their place.
π¬ The Postman's letters
Every night, the Postman sends a letter. The recipient is tapped in secret, while all eyes are closed β and the letter itself is the last thing the town hears before waking. Nobody opens their eyes until the punchline lands. And the Postman isβ¦ not well:
"He'd like to take you for a walk⦠off a cliff."
"He wants to feed you⦠to a woodchipper."
"He'd love to baptize you⦠until the bubbles stop."
The letters don't kill. They're clues. Who's been getting mail? Who claims they have? Who's lying about it? Track the letters to find the Postman before you vote him out by mistake β and if the letters ever stop comingβ¦ the Postman may already be in the Graveyard.
The Undertaker
The first person killed by the Mafia becomes the Undertaker. They stay awake through every night, see the whole truth, and manage the dead. Dead men tell no tales.
π― Inquire of the dead
Once per game, during Deliberation, any player may call to Inquire of the Dead.
The blind vote: the town closes its eyes and votes by raised hand. It takes two-thirds of the living to open the veil.
The price: if it passes, it replaces that day's Trial β no one is sentenced today. Choose wisely: answers or justice, never both.
The answer: the town agrees on one yes-or-no question and asks it aloud. The Undertaker answers for the Graveyard β one knock for yes, two for no. Any question is fair game. Even "Is [name] in the Mafia?" β you paid a full day for it, and the Mafia still gets their night.
Dead men tell no tales⦠except once.